Looking for Waterford? We are returning to our original name, Elms Puzzles. Click to learn more.

Replacement Piece(s)

To make replacement pieces, we require the surrounding pieces of the missing or damaged piece to be provided to us. This creates a ‘frame’ around the area that allows us to recreate a piece.

We ask that you place no tape, glue or other adhesive to the surrounding puzzle pieces. A safe way to send the surrounding pieces to us is to sandwich them between pieces of cardboard that are secured by a rubber band.

Each piece to be replaced is $79.  Please choose the number of pieces to be replaced when purchasing this service.


Ship the surrounding pieces with the puzzle’s title and puzzle number (if available) to:

The Waterford Puzzle Company

20492 Oakbrook Road, #463

Whitewood, SD 57793